
The 2008 NFL draft went for the Giants much like I thought it would. As worried as I am about Kenny Phillips being a difference maker (in the positive sort of way) I knew Reese and Co. were going to end up taking him with the 31st pick. Although I was holding out hope that Jarod Mayo would fall that far, I didn’t think there was much of a chance of that happening. I did not think he would go as high as ten, but after Keith Rivers (surprising to me) went at nine to the Bengals, I wasn’t shocked to see New England address their biggest weakness at ten with Mayo. It’s no secret that the Giants NEED a safety, and picking Phillips in the first round was probably the right move, but I just don’t love it. The guy is a hell of an athlete, but he makes a lot of mistakes that he just can’t afford to make in the NFL. I’m hoping he’s coachable enough to let Spagnoulo rid him of the false steps and misreads. If that happens, Phillips could be a potential Pro Bowler and more than worthy of the 31st pick in this draft.
In the second round the Giants decided to go cornerback and picked Terrell Thomas out of USC. I had a feeling the Giants would choose another corner early in this draft, but with Tavares Gooden out of Miami still on the board I think I would have rather seen New York take a chance with him at outside linebacker. It’s debatable which position is a greater need for Big Blue and I thought there was a little more depth at corner with a guy like Tyvonn Branch still available to them in round three. I also thought they could take a chance on Zach Bowman in the fourth or fifth round (he ended up going early in the fifth) and try to develop his undeniable talent. Still, Terrell Thomas is a talented defensive back in his own right and can certainly be a number two or three corner for Steve Spagnoulo’s defense.
Even though they passed on Tavares Gooden, the Giants did not ignore their need for help at linebacker and snagged two of them, selecting Bryan Kehl of BYU in the fourth round and Jonathan Goff from Vandy in the fifth. The Giants traded up to get Kehl and I like the move. He’s a big, athletic kid that can put on more bulk, which could help him overcome one of his weaknesses – shedding blocks. He’s fast enough to cover sideline to sideline against the run and covers good ground in a zone against the pass. Also, character is not an issue for this guy — he missed two years in college while on a Mormon mission, which automatically makes him a better man than I am. Goff is a very similar player, both in what he does well and what he needs to work on, though not graded as high as Kehl. My one problem with Goff is that he looks like he’s the younger brother of Terrell Owens. All indications are that he’s not nearly the douche TO is, but the resemblance makes me uneasy.
The Giants made two great value picks in the 2008 draft. The first was taking fallen angel Andre Woodson at the end of the sixth round. At the beginning of the season, Woodson was projected as a top pick. He has prototypical NFL size and arm strength with great touch on the deep ball and tremendous accuracy. He can put the right zip on the ball to hit the deep out and fire the ball into small holes over the middle. Woodson saw his stock plummet towards the end of the season as NFL scouts noticed a hitch in his delivery, causing him to take too long to get rid of the ball. He also showed a tendency to lock onto his number one receiver. Still, I don’t think many people figured Andre to drop all the way to the end of the sixth round and I love that the Giants stole him there even though Eli Manning (not exactly an old man) just led them to a Super Bowl championship. Woodson could develop into a more than capable backup and may eventually replace Eli, or serve as attractive trade bait.
The other value pick the Giants made was at receiver in the third round, but not the receiver I was calling for pre-draft at that spot. Shockingly, Donnie Avery was the FIRST receiver to come off the board at 33 to the Rams. I don’t think most people had him in the top ten receivers chosen in their mock drafts, I know I certainly didn’t. I also didn’t think there was any chance Mario “Eli” Manningham would last so long, but he did. Manningham is fast (faster than his 40 would indicate) and runs great routes; he just flat-out knows how to get open. His stock fell because of character questions, but Jerry Reese interviewed him thoroughly and ultimately gave his stamp of approval. After last year, that’s good enough for me. Manningham is the receiver the Giants need to stretch the field and provide that home run threat. My guess is that the Giants were looking to go linebacker with this pick, but when they saw Manningham still on the board when they were put on the clock they couldn’t pass him up. I love this pick.
Overall I could justify grading this year’s draft for the Giants anywhere in the C- to B+ range. They addressed their biggest areas of need and drafted some very talented players, including some potential gems in the later rounds. As most of you know, I’m not yet sold on Kenny Phillips, but I can’t fault the Giants at all for drafting him with their 1st rounder as they desperately needed a safety with the ability to cover speedy slot receivers as well as help stop the run. Still, some had him as the second best safety in a weak safety draft class, and he really doesn’t provide first round value. On the other hand, Mario Manningham could wind up being the steal of the 2008 Draft. Plus, after the draft Jerry Reese and his boys had last year, I have to give them the benefit of the doubt this time around. Grade: B