
Well everyone– that day is finally here… the day when the question on everyone’s mind will finally be answered: “Where the hell has Monnie D been???” Ok, well, maybe not. We have more important things to discuss today, and no, it has nothing to do with the election. You Subway Chatter loyalists already have a pretty good idea as to where I stand on it.
That being the case, I’m going to take some time here to de-stress, which is probably a good idea considering I could be in line for a complete nervous breakdown when the numbers start coming in tonight (that said, I think we’re all in for a big surprise this evening). So, instead of more mubojumbo about fixing our country, let’s talk about something a little less important: revamping the Yanks (emphasis on the word “little”
). The free agent season is upon us, and along with it the Yanks’ only shot to turn this thing around and get it going in the right direction.
Before I get into the nitty-gritty, I offer this disclaimer: this shouldn’t, and won’t be, the monumental task everyone is making it out to be. Do we have to leap-frog two teams to get back to the top of the AL East heap? Yes. But let’s look at things realistically here instead of focusing on the ridiculous, fear-mongering headlines we read all season-long in the Post, Dailynews, Newsday, etc. etc. (You know, sort of like the presidential polls). THE YANKEES WON 89 GAMES LAST YEAR!!! No, your eyes do not deceive you– 89 games. If you didn’t know any better, the likes of Mike Lupica, Joel Sherman, and Mike Francessa on the broadcast end, would have you convinced that they finished 75-and-87 and were an absolutel joke. And you know, most Yankee fans started to buy into this clap-trap (I guess this was a portent of the gullibility to follow regarding more serious matters). But let’s be rational here: what other team could lose their ace– a guy who had won 19-games the past two season– their all-star catcher– who is not only one of their best hitters and leading RBI guys, but is the de facto team captain– their starting left-fielder– who just happens to be a 100-RBI guy himself– and still finish just one game shy of 90 wins??? And that’s forgetting all the other injuries (Jetes, A-rod, Joba, Hughes, Kennedy…). All I’m trying to say is, if B-Ca$h is successful in at least achieving his off-season goal of improving the starting pitching, then the Yanks will be right where they need to be next April.
But the goal here isn’t just to get back in the thick of things. The Yanks are trying to get back to where things were almost a decade ago (can’t believe it’s been that long). The way things are in baseball today, I’m not sure we’ll be seeing dynasties any time soon. But the Yanks can definitely be a World Series contender year-in-and-year-out if nothing else, and that’s something we haven’t been able to say about them since 2003. So here’s how they’re going to do it:
1) Sign CC Sabathia: this one’s obvious. Just gotta throw all kinds of money at the guy and get it done. I’m convinced that much of the motivation which led the Yanks not to trade Hughes and bit parts for Johan Santana last year was because they knew they could make a run at Sabathia with dollar signs alone, not a combination of those and top prospects. If that’s been your plan for a year running, then you absolutely HAVE to make it happen.
2) Sign any one of the 2nd-tier starters not named Ben Sheets: that includes Oliver Perez. Any one of Perez, Derek Lowe, or AJ Burnett improves the rotation. Burnett is obviously the top choice from this group, but I like Perez a lot. He’s a lefty, for one, and he can pitch in NY, which none of the others have proved. Though I trust Lowe because of his big-game pedigree. A lot of people don’t like him because he doesn’t fit the dominant starter mold. But the Yankees don’t necessarily need that. In fact, should they sign Sabathia, they’ll potentially have three of them in their rotation: CC, Wang, and Joba. What they do need are 5 starters who are capable of reaching double-digits in the win column, and Lowe meets that criteria. Here’s my order of preference: Burnett, Perez, Lowe.
3) Bring back Mussina and/or Pettitte: I would bring back ONE of the two, not both. The Yanks are obviously at the mercy of Mussina because it’s unclear if he even wants to keep playing. I never, in a million years, thought I’d say this, but he would be my first choice here. I don’t think people realize how unbelievably good he was in ‘08. Sure he had the 20 wins, but he was dominant while doing so. It wasn’t like a typical Wang season where he gets 19 wins but get smacked around 5 or 6 times on the way there. Other than the hiccups against the Sox to start the year, Mussina owned. Still, if he says “no thanks” and rides off into the sunset, Andy’s a reasonable alternative. He was injured during the second-half and still managed to win 14 games. Not bad. Not bad at all.
4) Sign a cheap, fringe 5th starter: someone’s gotta give Joba a start or two off from time-to-time to keep him fresh and injury-free. It’s not Sergio Mitre, who we signed last week, ’cause he won’t be ready until July following Tommy John surgery. This person may already exist in the form of Phil Hughes or Alfredo Aceves, but I’d kick the tires on– gulp– Carl Pavano too. I won’t even bother to explain why ’cause a number of you probably closed your browser after reading that, but Aceves and/or Hughes could be valuable trade chips and may be used to pry loose a 1st baseman, so we could have to turn elsewhere.
Ok so let’s re-cap real quick: if the Yanks follow my advice, here’s next year’s rotation– Sabathia, Wang, Burnett, Mussina/Pettitte, Joba, Joba’s caddy. Even if it looks like this– Sabathia, Wang, Mussina/Pettitte, Perez/Lowe, Joba, Joba’s caddy– it’s still pretty sick. It’s at least as good as Boston’s, if not better, and it can absolutely compete with the Rays’ staff too. In fact, expect the Rays’ youngsters to slump moderately following a season in which they all threw more innings than they ever had before (take a look at what’s happened to the Tigers since they burned out Verlander, Robertson, and Bonderman in ‘06). Now on to the bats…
1) DO NOT SIGN MARK TEIXEIRA: What happened the last time we gave more than 5-years to a first baseman who was entering his 30s? Granted, Big Tex’s body won’t fall apart like Jason Giambi’s did ’cause he hasn’t been abusing steroids since he was 21, but I just don’t like the idea. Instead, put the money to better use elsewhere…
2) SIGN MANNY RAMIREZ: give me one good reason why we shouldn’t? Alright, fine, maybe I shouldn’t have asked that question. But still, look at what the Red Sox were able to accomplish with a duo of Big Papi and Senor Lice-hair: two championships in four years. Imagine A-rod batting third, with Manny protecting him in the cleanup spot? For one, it’s a hell of a lot better than protecting him with Giambi. And second, it’ll make the entire lineup that much better. Again, see exhibit A: the ‘04-’07 Red Sox. If that doesn’t convince you, check exhibit B: the August-October ‘08 Dodgers. Manny single-handedly carried them to the NLCS in a sport where one-man teams are often last-place teams. And with him in the lineup, it will allow the Yanks to be more cost-efficient in other areas, namely at 1st base and centerfield. He would primarily serve as a DH, but could spell Damon in left-field to prevent some of the bumps and bruises that Damon will inevitably accumulate over the course of the season. I wouldn’t give Manny more than 3 years, but if we can blow him away with money, we gotta try.
3) Trade Hideki Matsui: having signed Manny to DH, and with Damon installed as our LF, Matsui is eminently expendable. He has a full no-trade clause, so it’ll be tough to do coming off an injury-plagued ‘08, but I’m thinking Hideki is the kind of guy who won’t want to stay somewhere that he isn’t wanted. This should follow the mold of the Sheffield trade: find a team that thinks they are a professional hitter away from competing, and then trade Matsui for a decent sum of prospects. This team could be the Dodgers (especially if Manny is gone) or the Rangers (Matsui could hit 40 homers playing 81 games in the Texas heat). I don’t really care where he goes as long as he does.
4) Give the Rockies a call: first baseman Garret Atkins is available, and so is center-fielder Wily Taveras. What a coincidence– the Yanks have needs at both spots! SI’s Jon Heyman heard rumblings that a Taveras for Kennedy deal was in the offing. Obviously it will take more than that to get Atkins as well. I’m thinking something along the lines of the Nady deal where we give up four or five prospects, all with a decent ceiling, but none of a top-tier caliber. So maybe Kennedy, Brett Gardner, Aceves, and one other Double-A pitcher (the Rox always need plenty of that). Atkins made close to $5 million last year and is arbitration eligible; ditto for Taveras, who made a little more than a million. By the way, Atkins will be 29 next year and Taveras will be 27 (and he stole 68 bases in ‘08). There’s that youth movement we’ve been talking about.
K, time to recap: if the Yanks follow this plan, here’s next year’s lineup–
1) Damon
2) Jeter
3) A-rod
4) Manny
5) Posada
6) Nady
7) Cano
8) Atkins
9) Taveras
So you basically have two leadoff hitters in Damon and Taveras, the middle of the lineup is un-pitchable, and our 6 and 8 guys both had more than 20 dingers and close to a 100 RBIs last year. And if Cano rebounds? All I’m gonna say is, I like this lineup… A LOT.
Alright, Subway Chatter nation, I hope you like the Yanks’ new look. If not… or if you just want to throw some other ideas out there… give me a shout below. And oh yeah– GET OUT THE VOTE!!!